Fact check: Do ice have higher detention standards than prisons in the United States? | Migration News

Democratic members of the Congress, which saw Florida’s new immigration control center, Alligator Alcatrazdozens of metal covers, buks and mosquitoes witness dozens of people, 80 degrees and a person who shouted for help in the buck’s areas, he said.

Republicans, who browsing the enterprise, tell a different story that describes the gap as a safe, clean and good run. The Federal Homeland Security Department, which controls immigration control, called the State Alligor Alcatraz called “false” in non-adequate conditions.

Civic Secretary Christi Noem, the Democrats’ accounts were given an interview on “Get acquainted with the press” on July 13. According to him, the Florida-Run rig said that “the highest level for the federal government is the highest level for detention facilities.”

“Our federal pre-trial detention facilities have a higher standard than most local or state centers and even federal prisons,” he said. “Standards are extremely high.”

White House Border Tour Tom Homan also touched upon the standards of the immigration investigation of the nation due to prisons and prisons.

A correspondent Homan’s 75-year-old Cuban person in prison in June in June, about 65-year-old Cuban man, said Miami was in prison in Homan Federal Federal Federal Foundations.

“People die Ice (Immigration and customs execution) was taken into custody, “the highest detention standards in the industry.” See yourself, then come back and talk to me. “

Isidro Perez was the 11th person to die in ice control over six months in about six months. Twelve people died during the last fiscal year for the former President Joe Biden.

Ice pre-trial detention facilities have standards for prisons. However, compared to several reasons, it is difficult to evaluate quilt expressions on immigration control standards compared to local or other federal facilities.

• Ice investigation standards are not coded to the law, so it is difficult to apply them.
• Different ice investigation centers meet different standards according to their terms of individual agreements.
• There is no set of standards for local, state and federal prisons and prisons. Some standards are mandatory or coded to the law, but not others.

Several government guards, propaganda organizations and news reports are immigration pre-trial detention facilities for a long time inadequate conditions.

In May, the Human Rights Group Amnesty International said, “Dishes, insufficient toilets, irreplaceable, unusual and full of guards, non-sufficient toilets, and poor food, use of poor food, finished dishes, finished dishes and food used in poor food.

Lauren Brinkley-Rubinstein, a Duke University Associate Professor, learning the health effects of the criminal legal system, called Homan’s “very wrong” expression.

“In many ways, ice facilities are operated by less consistent control and legal accountability from state or federal prisons or local prisons,” Brinkley-Rubinstein said. “Ice pre-trial detention facilities and people who work them are less transparent about their operations.”

Have the storage standards of ice, but they are not applicable in law or at all

Several federal agencies and private companies manage immigration pre-trial detention facilities. The main agency in charge of the immigration investigation has the standards of all pre-trials.

For example, the objects should be sanitary and there are drinking water. The detainees must get access to medical and mental health, including recipe medications. When physical power is only “necessary and reasonable”, it is not like a punishment. And prisoners should be able to meet with lawyers secretly.

There are different standards for various objects for other immigrants, such as immigrant prisoners and other non-immigrants related to local prisons and other immigrants.

“Standards of centers that are not based on many prison standards are based on many prisoners” Rules of use of many prisoners “, Prof. Right to Michigan.

Which standards are not known Alligator Alcatraz is caught. Although the courts have repeatedly held a federal responsibility for the immigration, which are repeatedly held a federal responsibility, the center is Runay. However, in a judicial declaration, an ice officer Thomas P Giles, said the agency walks the object “to ensure matching of ice detention standards.”

The sets of both immigration standards are periodically updated, but the updated ice standards are updated and there is no time between other facilities updates. The standards are being negotiated individually and “Rates of different degree in prisons”, about immigration to the research article of the 2021 Harvard Law

In addition, the detention standards are not coded by law, complicate their implementation. Prisoners ‘complaints’ conditions, industry, because the industry has little legal support to stand because of its self-regulation, defended an immigration scientist.

“Standards are often only rules and mostly valid. They are favorable and weak,” David Hernández, David Hernández, David Hernández, David Hernández, said a professor specializing in deportation policy. “Very few devices lose their contracts for the deaths of prayers or even prisoners.”

Government Guards, Non-Commercial Institution, News Inadequate Terms in Storage Centers

The Homeland Security Administration is mainly responsible for conducting inspections to ensure the response of the centers of the elders. However, for years, the government has surveyed the effectiveness of these studies and the effectiveness of these studies and in accordance with ice standards.

In 2020, Congress established an office of Immudritation Immudsman, which allows unauthorized research to the Ombudsman of Immigration Arrest Ombudsman and the permission of immigrants.

In March, Trump management tried to close the office. A civil rights group sued the management. In response, the DHS said the office will remain open, but in a declaration he said with a smaller staff. Immigration specialists said that the control centers of this decision were severely limited to the control.

News and advocacy organizations, including an extreme degree, also warned that immigration pre-trial detention facilities are insufficient. Trump Management is currently retention About 60,000 people are more people than financing Congress to capture 1,000 people.

Foreign reports rejection of the medical care of prisoners in various places in private assistance for placing a private prison, legal sources and medical care for legal services after complaining of medical services. Catholic University Immigration Right Professor Stacy Brustin, “mirror accounts” of these stories, and their disciples witnessed several arrest centers.

“Detained toilets, sewage leaks, non-sufficient medical care, protective or impossible food, spoiled or impossible food, spoiled or impossible, and” Brustin “.” All of these conditions violate ice storage standards. “

For example, ICE standards say centers should be “a balanced diet made in sanitation and hygienic and a nourished balanced balanced diet.” The spoiled food is a breach.

Differences between ice storage and prison standards

Some states have coded the standards that pre-trial detention facilities are required. Some objects are accredited by the American Reform Association, which has their own standards.

All opportunities must follow the US Constitution – especially the acceptance of “cruelty and unusual punishments”, especially in criminal cases, and the adoption of “Amendment 14 protection from property, not the right to property, not the right to property. Prisons and prisons and prisons, sexual violence, prisoners must also comply with the federal laws on their access to religious facilities and disability.

“Courts have the right to take care of people arrested on these devices, security and human treatment,” said Brinkley-Rubinstein.

In general, there are similar provisions for the immigration investigation, such as prison and prison standards, health and legal sources and sanitary facilities.

Control practices also vary according to the object. Some places are taken into custody independently; Others only trust internal controls.

The results of prisons and prisons that do not comply with the standards are changing.

“If the enterprise is under decree and judicial control, the judge may require regular reports, to make all aspects of the enterprise,” said Andrea Armstrong, Loyola University, New Orleans Professor and Prison Conditions Specialist.

According to Schlanger, some places may lose their contracts depending on the severity of the situation. In other cases, the facilities may face court claims.

There are more restrictions when trying to apply to courts to join the courts. The reason for this is more of a crime from the crime of crime.

This classification “creates a dangerous gap that people can be held in carceral conditions without the preservation of constitution in the criminal legal system,” Brinkley-Rubinstein said.